We Have to Commercialize Thanksgiving
My five-point plan for winning The War of Christmas Aggression. PLUS: Food, drink, music, books, pets and more as we approach Turkey Day!
Something's been troubling me the past few weeks–the past few years, really.
Thanksgiving is losing ground.
This becomes plainly evident on November 1st, when social media is flooded with videos of people flipping the switch straight from Halloween's "spooky season" into full-on North Pole Mode. No sooner do the fake spiderwebs come down than the strings of Christmas lights rise in their place, and there's nary a second thought given to what belongs in between. It's long been a rallying cry for culture-warriors to claim that there's a "War on Christmas", but take a look around: Christmas is the one invading, and poor little Thanksgiving doesn't stand a chance.
I say it's time to fight back.
Thanksgiving is my favorite holiday of the year, and I can't stand by and watch it get steamrolled by the territorial ambitions of an imperial Christmas. It pains me to say it, but if the fourth Thursday in November is to survive as an independent holiday and not a puppet state under the fist of "Black Friday Week", it's going to have to arm itself with the same weapons as its enemy.
We have to commercialize Thanksgiving.
Don't get me wrong: I'm not looking to destroy Christmas. I enjoy the Yuletide season as much as one should. My goal is only to force it back within its lawfully-recognized borders, a season that does not begin until the day after Thanksgiving.
To that end, I've assembled a five-point plan for success.
Songs
Nowhere is Christmas's asymmetric advantage more readily apparent than over the radio waves. There are hundreds of Christmas songs. Thousands. There's Christmas songs in every genre from hip-hop to country to whatever the hell "Wonderful Christmastime" is. There are entire radio stations dedicated to this stuff, and one could easily fill the entire season without repeating a song.
What does Thanksgiving have? "Alice's Restaurant".
Now, I love a mildly-annoying eighteen-minute folk song as much as anyone, but putting that up against "Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)" is like a tank battalion with riders on horseback. We need at least one absolute banger of a Thanksgiving song, and it needs to be the work of a genuine pop icon. If Michael Jackson could make a Halloween song an all-time classic, there's no reason that Taylor Swift can't make a song about about stuffing.
[touches earpiece] no I've heard "Wood" that's not what I mean
Characters
"Wait, but Thanksgiving has characters," you say.
That's true. Generations of American grade-schoolers have learned a version of the story of the "first Thanksgiving", but that story's awfully fraught with the baggage of colonialism, and the fact that the Pilgrims were Puritanical weirdos.
We need to expand our horizons.
Christmas is definitionally the story of Jesus's birth, but that hasn't stopped popular culture from creating all sorts of totally-unrelated fictional characters like Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer, Frosty the Snowman, the Grinch, Ebenezer Scrooge and Michael Bublé.
What I'm proposing is a whole McDonaldland-level cast of Thanksgiving characters with their own poems and songs and animated specials. Cary the Cranberry Capybara. Gravy Dave. The Yamburgler. Mac and Cheese, a pair of roughhousing mischievous twins. We could even have a villain: Cousin Cathy Who Always Brings a Salad to Thanksgiving. They're not all going to be winners, but if Hollywood can make an Ebenezer Scrooge origin story movie (??), then we can stop-motion-animate a pile of mashed potatoes that turns into a town-saving golem. Nay: we have to.
Speaking of characters...
Child-terrorizing interactive traditions
Even with overwhelming historical success, Christmas hasn't stopped developing new weapons. Given its unfortunate cultural ubiquity these days, it's easy to forget that the "Elf on the Shelf" wasn't introduced until 2005. In the past 21 years, the concept of a doll that hides around your house and snitches on your children has been widely-accepted as part of Christmas lore.
We don't need to reinvent the wheel here: we just need to steal their weapon and repackage it. I'm proposing The Turkey Lurker, a small stuffed turkey that parents can hide around the house. Once a day, it will emit an ear-splitting alarm noise that children can only deactivate by stating three things they are grateful for.
"But Scott, that's a horrible idea."
So is the Elf on the Shelf. Wars aren't won by being nobler than your enemy.
Countdowns
The tradition of Advent calendars has been around for hundreds of years, but in recent years, the practice has exploded well beyond simple cardboard packages concealing small chocolates to daily countdowns of things like Legos, jellies, hot sauces, whiskies–if you can imagine it, someone's putting it into an Advent calendar.
(Don't get me started on the 12-day ones. That's not the right number.)
Anyways, Thanksgiving should have a countdown tradition too. It doesn't always fall on the same date, but it's always the fourth Thursday in November: we simply need to make the each of the other three Thursdays into holidays where we give each other fun things like books or stuffed animals or subscriptions to The Action Cookbook Newsletter.
(Hey, I'm not above some light war profiteering.)
Speaking of countdowns, though...
An official kickoff ceremony
Despite its deep incursions into early November, the Christmas season at least purports to have an official start. Unfortunately, it's on Thanksgiving, before the turkey's even hit the table in most households. The Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade is a Thanksgiving event in name only; in reality, it's the most brazen symbol of Christmas aggression that there is–the holiday's most commercial character marching through Manhattan like the general of a triumphant army.
If we're going to win any ground back for Thanksgiving, we need an equal show of force. That's why I'm proposing that every November 1st, we have a nationally-televised event where a gigantic frozen turkey is ceremonially lowered into a too-full turkey fryer.
It's not just a party. It's an overwhelming display of force.
Friends, it's Friday again at The Action Cookbook Newsletter.
Of course, I jest.
The reason I love Thanksgiving so much is because it can't be commercialized in the way that Christmas or Halloween or Valentine's Day might be. Instead, it's a day to rest and rejoice, a day to share good food with the people we love and be grateful for the blessings bestowed on us.
On this final Friday before the holiday, I'm gearing up–I've got my latest spin on a few of my annual Thanksgiving-table pleas, some lovely new music, a cozy book, reader-submitted pets, and more!

Gobble up.
Once again I must implore you to get your berries hot
Every year that this newsletter has existed, I have made a plea at Thanksgiving, and that's that you should make Hot Cranberry Sauce.

Cranberry sauce has an important place at the Thanksgiving table; it's a necessary jolt of acid in an otherwise starch-and-fat-heavy meal. That said, I was never a big fan of it growing up; some people might enjoy the ridged cylinder of jelly that comes out of a can, but I do not. That changed for me when I realized how easy and fun it is to make fresh: you dump a bag of fresh berries into a pot with some sugar, a little orange juice and maybe a cinnamon stick, heat it up, and watch it miraculously turn into sauce.
That basic formula is ripe for tinkering, and in 2019 I first proposed using it as a vehicle for another element the Thanksgiving table usually lacks: heat. In that first iteration, I sauteed fresh hot peppers (serrano, jalapeno and habanero) before blending them into the sauce. It was great, even if I gassed out the house doing so.
(I have since learned to do this outside on the grill's side burner.)
In subsequent years, this has become as essential a part of my Thanksgiving table as the stuffing or gravy, but I've experimented with a lot of different versions of it. I've used canned chipotle peppers in lieu of fresh, or gochujang in lieu of peppers.
Well, I'm tinkering again.
